If you love Ben and Jerry’s Milk and Cookies Ice Cream, you will absolutely swoon over my homemade recipe!
Milk and Cookies Ice Cream

Little did I tell you that when we spent Labor Day weekend in Ogunquit, Maine last year, we hit up the Ben & Jerry’s shop every single day.

And ummm, I think there was a day (or two?) when we were there twice.

It was the only ice cream shop in town that we knew of and it was in keeping with our daily tradition when we’re in Lake George as well. I figure that all the walking (and sweating) we do when we’re on summer vacation more than makes up for the daily ice cream romps.

As do the salads we eat for days on end when we get home.

Milk and Cookies Ice Cream

And it was in Ogunquit that I first tasted Ben & Jerry’s Milk & Cookies ice cream flavor. I was really craving cookies and cream but this was my closest option and man, did this flavor knock my socks off!

It’s no more than a simple vanilla ice cream with a cookie swirl, chocolate chips, and chocolate chip cookies. Not cookie dough – COOKIES!

Milk and Cookies Ice Cream

The chocolate chip cookies make this ice cream insanely addictive and I’ve been holding off until this summer to make my own version.

Ingredients

Here’s the basic shopping list for this ice cream recipe. Be sure to check out the full list in the recipe card below!

  • egg yolks
  • granulated sugar
  • heavy cream
  • whole milk
  • coarse salt
  • pure vanilla extract
  • chocolate chip cookies – homemade or store-bought
  • Oreo cookies

For my version, I mixed in chunks of my absolute favorite chocolate chip cookies and chopped Oreos into vanilla ice cream.

And then Kyle and I proceeded to stand over the container with spoons even before the ice cream was fully frozen. It was so worth the wait!

Milk and Cookies Ice Cream

If you want to skip the Oreos and make this a full-on homemade ice cream, simply crumble up some chocolate wafer cookies in place of the Oreos. Those cookies are SO delicious that you won’t even miss the cream filling!

Milk and Cookies Ice Cream

Milk and Cookies Ice Cream

Yield: about 1 ½ quarts
Prep Time: 15 minutes
Cook Time: 15 minutes
Chill Time: 12 hours
Total Time: 12 hours 30 minutes

My milk and cookies ice cream was inspired by too many trips to the Ben & Jerry's ice cream shop during one of our vacations. I loved this ice cream so much that I decided I needed to make a copycat version at home. Made with my favorite homemade chocolate chip cookies and chopped Oreos, this version beats out any $5+ plus pint you can buy!

Ingredients

  • 5 large egg yolks
  • ½ cup granulated sugar, divided
  • 1 ¾ cups heavy cream
  • ¾ cup whole milk
  • ¼ tsp coarse salt
  • 2 tsp pure vanilla extract
  • 4 to 6 homemade chocolate chip cookies
  • 1 cup chopped Oreo cookies (about 8-10 cookies)

Instructions

  1. Set a mesh strainer over a medium bowl. Fill a larger bowl about halfway full with ice and water.
  2. Add the egg yolks to a medium heatproof bowl. Whisk in ¼ cup sugar until the sugar dissolves; set aside.
  3. In a medium saucepan set over medium heat, whisk the remaining ¼ cup sugar, heavy cream, milk, and salt together. Once the mixture starts to steam, remove it from the heat. Using a ladle, scoop out some of the milk mixture from the pan and slowly stream it into the egg mixture, whisking quickly to ensure the eggs don't cook. (Tip: it helps tremendously here to set the bowl on a non-slip oven mitt or Silpat to keep the bowl from sliding around while you're whisking.) Repeat this two more times then whisk the egg mixture into the milk mixture in the saucepan. Bring the mixture to a low simmer and cook until the mixture thickens and just coats the back of a spoon, about 1 to 2 minutes.
  4. Pour the mixture through the mesh strainer, pressing out all of the liquid and catching any cooked egg bits that remain. Stir in the vanilla extract.
  5. Set the bowl inside the larger bowl on top of the ice bath and allow the mixture to cool while stirring occasionally. Once the ice cream base has cooled, cover the bowl tightly and refrigerate for 4 hours or overnight.
  6. Freeze the ice cream base in an ice cream maker according to the manufacturer's instructions. Transfer the soft ice cream to a resealable container and stir in the chopped cookies. Seal the container and freeze for at least 6 hours before serving.

Notes

You'll need about ¼ of the chocolate chip cookie recipe I've listed below (or about 4-6 cookies). I made the whole recipe - because, why not?? - and baked off a few extra cookies while freezing a bunch of dough balls as well. Nobody complained about having extra homemade cookies.

inspired by Ben & Jerry's | ice cream adapted from this cookies and cream ice cream

Recommended Products

As a member of the Amazon Associate affiliate program, I earn a small percentage from your qualifying Amazon purchases when you click the Amazon links on this page. I'm not informed of who purchases what, just of what products are purchased.

How much do you love this recipe?

Follow Smells Like Home on Pinterest and click that little Pin button at the top of this recipe card to save this recipe and share with your Pinterest followers!